I watched Tony Robbins’ new Breakthrough show last night on NBC, and read many of the comments in the Huffington Post this morning regarding it. Here’s what were among the top 20:
Cookerman45 said that he was “tony the cult master“.
Jebbushnot said that “This guy has been a ‘new age’ hustler since the late 1970′s when he charged believers $200 to walk across hot coals in their bare feet….this was in Del Mar, CA. I know a 24 year old women who paid her money and ended up in the hospital with burns on her feet.“
Duhtruth said “This is a joke of major proportions. The only thing I hope is that one of the razor companies supports Tony. He is in need of a decent shave. Looks like he just came from a homeless shelter.“
UnrepentantProgressive said this: “Does Tony Robbins advocate for higher taxes on the wealthy? For a federal work force for the long-term unemployed? For an end to credit card usury? These things would really help people out, millions of people. I mean, no problem if he just focuses on helping individuals out, but we need more inspiration that just “think positive.” We need political and socio-economic revolution. Seriously, I’m asking because I don’t know much about the guy, and have never found motivational speakers very interesting. Does he ever advocate on macro-level, cultural issues?“
Here’s my problem with these comments:
1) Not ONE single comment or kudo to who was actually the focus of the show, Frank and Kristen Alioto. Not one word about their incredible struggle, the personal transformation they went through over the 30 days, or their amazing results. Maybe it’s just these blog commenters, but I thought people on the left were supposed to be so much more compassionate? Or, are we that conceited and self-absorbed?
2) The personal attacks on Tony Robbins. People can like him or not like him, that’s their choice, but the comments from these people are pure ignorance. Here’s why:
1. Tony Robbins is no more a ‘cult master’ than an Arianna Huffington is.
2. Robbins has not only produced results in his OWN life, but in OTHER peoples’ lives as well. How many of us can say we’ve done the same? Of the commenters above, I’d say ZERO, in large part due to the fact that their own lives are miserable (no one with their discourse is truly happy).
3. Anyone who’s actually gone through Robbins’ material or his seminars knows that it is NOT about positive thinking. If you want that, go to “The Secret” and waste your life there. The cornerstone of Robbins’ material is about action, not thought.
4. People who are successful (or have become successful) have found Robbins’ material to be very useful, whereas those who have made nothing of their lives haven’t. That’s a clue, people.
5. Only people who firewalk incorrectly – i.e. those who don’t follow the instructions – will burn their feet. I’ve firewalked many times, and the only way someone could end up in hospital is if they deliberately stood still on the coals.
3) “Does Robbins advocate for higher taxes on the wealthy?… an end to credit card usury?”
I can’t speak for him, but I think Robbins would likely say that people should focus on their own lives first before projecting their problems onto someone else’s. The rich aren’t responsible for people’s happiness or hardship and neither are the credit card companies. Don’t like the interest rates? Don’t get a credit card! What made you get one in the first place, and what made you need to carry a balance? I’d also challenge any of these commenters to make a list of everything they’ve done in their life to get ahead vs. someone who has become successful on their own, and see what the differences are. Judging by their discourse, I’m guessing there would be many. Want to advocate something? Then be an example, don’t just yap.
These comments exemplify what I think is wrong with America, and that’s people not owning their own problems. Life’s not miserable because there are credit card companies, life coaches, firewalkers, or big-headed transformation experts out there. Life is miserable for people because MOST people give up control of their lives and then turn around and bitch when it doesn’t go their way.
The Aliotos seemed to have almost given up, but they didn’t. They took ownership of their lives and responsibility for their own happiness. Refocusing upon what they had vs. what they didn’t, they were able to pull themselves out of their situation and I’m assuming continue to be much happier and better off as a result.
To anyone who didn’t watch the show, I’d recommend watching if for no other reason than to see how two people with problems likely far worse than our own got through them, and to share in what I thought was a truly inspiring story. Seeing Kristen’s smile change alone was worth the hour of time, and Robbins should be commended overall for what he helped accomplish.
**** UPDATE ****
I’ve continued to catch comments from critics and the only criticisms I’ve seen so far that have had any substance are those which say that the show felt too rushed, which I agree with but have no idea how that problem could be solved packing so much into an hour.
Perhaps a workaround, though, is the “behind the scenes” Insider area that I happened upon. There, Robbins shares a lot of what we didn’t see on the TV show, and for me it provided much of the substance and “reality” that I was looking for from the show itself.
Robbins talks more about his time with the couple and the extent of the struggles they had even being on the show. He shares the story of how Frank was actually dropped (yes, DROPPED!) by staff not once but TWICE, and how much of a struggle emotionally it was for both Frank and Kristen to even get Frank out of the house, let alone get him on an 11 hour flight. After the second time Frank was dropped the couple apparently called Robbins and said, “That’s it! We’re done!”, but thankfully, they hung in there.
Hearing this “behind the scenes” story not only made the show that much more real and enjoyable to me, it also showed Robbins in a very “real” way as well. I don’t see how anyone can watch that extra clip and call the guy a phony. Robbins also shares some of his insights into the Alioto’s challenge, and I think he’s bang-on. I look forward to future episodes.